Because Canada does not look at the label. A border officer asks what your offence would be under Canadian law, and how serious Canada considers it. A charge that was minor where you live can match a Canadian offence that is not.
How Canada assesses a U.S. conviction
Canada's immigration law makes a person inadmissible for an offence committed outside Canada if it would also be an offence in Canada. Officers compare the U.S. offence with its closest Canadian equivalent.
The words misdemeanor and felony do not exist in Canadian criminal law, so they carry no weight in that comparison. What matters is the conduct, the statute you were convicted under, and the penalty the Canadian equivalent carries.
Two categories
Canada sorts offences by the maximum prison term the equivalent Canadian offence allows.
| Category | Canadian equivalent carries | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Criminality | A maximum sentence under ten years | Lower rehabilitation fee; Deemed Rehabilitation may be possible after ten years |
| Serious criminality | A maximum sentence of ten years or more | Higher rehabilitation fee; Deemed Rehabilitation is not available |
Notice that the test is the maximum the law allows, not the sentence you received. A small fine does not move an offence into the lower category.
The example that catches most people
Impaired driving is usually a misdemeanor in the United States for a first offence. In Canada it is a criminal offence, and since December 18, 2018 it has carried a maximum penalty that places it in serious criminality.
That is why an American with one DUI, a fine and no jail time can be refused entry.
Offences that commonly raise questions
- Impaired driving, including offences involving drugs or cannabis
- Theft and shoplifting
- Assault, including domestic incidents
- Drug possession
- Fraud and other dishonesty offences
Not every conviction makes someone inadmissible, and the answer for a given offence is not always obvious. The same charge name can describe different conduct from state to state.
What about more than one conviction?
Numbers matter. Deemed Rehabilitation is generally limited to people with a single conviction. With two or more, the usual route is an application for Criminal Rehabilitation once five years have passed since the last sentence ended.
Dismissed, deferred or expunged
These outcomes do not all mean the same thing, and Canada looks at what happened in substance.
- Dismissed or acquitted: generally there is no conviction to assess, but bring the court record that shows the outcome.
- Deferred or conditional outcomes: the treatment depends on the details of the program and whether there was a finding of guilt.
- Pardoned or expunged: Canada's guidance is to have the visa office confirm whether a foreign pardon or discharge is valid in Canada.
Do not assume either way. An officer may still see the original arrest and ask about it.
Convictions as a minor
Canada's guidance says a conviction that occurred when you were under 18 may not prevent you from entering. The details of how the case was handled matter, so this is worth checking rather than assuming.
What an officer may ask for
If your record comes up at the border, the officer will want facts, not explanations. Be ready to show:
- the statute you were convicted under
- the sentence the court imposed
- the date each part of the sentence was completed
Be truthful. Officers also assess other grounds of inadmissibility, and misstating your history can create a separate problem.
Finding out where you stand
Three facts answer most questions: the exact offence, the sentence, and the completion date. With those, it is usually possible to say which category applies and whether you need a Temporary Resident Permit, Criminal Rehabilitation, or a Deemed Rehabilitation document package for the border.
Read our guide to Deemed Rehabilitation, or ask us to review your situation before you book.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Eligibility depends on your circumstances, and approval is never guaranteed.
